Page 3 of 3
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Mon Feb 29, 2016 8:22 pm
by Reaser
TanksAndSpartans wrote:Thanks Reaser. What does it take for a HOVG candidate to be considered by the committee? Does the player have to be on a certain number/percentage of ballots?
All PFRA members can nominate five players/coaches - that have been retired at least 25 years.
The HOVG committee goes through all nominations and votes the list down to a final 20.
Those 20 are on the ballot and all PFRA members (that want to) vote for 10.
Those that were on 55% of the submitted ballots are elected.
There's been slight changes over the years (believe it started out as retired 20 years then bumped up to 25, for example) but that's how it is now.
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Mon Feb 29, 2016 8:53 pm
by ChrisBabcock
Those that were on 55% of the submitted ballots are elected.
Don't exactly 10 get elected every year though?
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Mon Feb 29, 2016 8:56 pm
by Reaser
ChrisBabcock wrote:Don't exactly 10 get elected every year though?
Nope. 7 last year. I believe 8 the year before, and so on.
Here's a list (at the bottom you can go year-by-year):
http://www.profootballresearchers.com/h ... y-good.htm
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Mon Feb 29, 2016 11:37 pm
by oldecapecod11
After tabulating a couple hundred ballots, it is strange that the vote count is never shared with the members?
Is there a reason that only the names of the chosen are announced and not the vote tally?
This might be very interesting data for potential members from the ladies' leagues.
If anyone is interested, a data base with all HOVG honorees is available so you can view it either
alphabetically or chronologically.
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2016 10:14 am
by TanksAndSpartans
Thanks - I just submitted my 2016 nominations after seeing the ad in my first Coffin Corner and I was curious about the process.
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2016 11:14 am
by ChrisBabcock
oh duh... That's right. I was thinking of the nominating process.
Re: Sporting News Top 10 HOF snubs
Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2022 4:38 am
by JWL
JWL wrote:My 10 in alphabetical order-
Robert Brazile
Lavvie Dilweg
Kenny Easley
Randy Gradishar
Chuck Howley
Lemar Parrish
Johnny Robinson
Sterling Sharpe
Duke Slater
Al Wistert
Sharpe was a superb receiver, maybe even top 10 all-time. Del Shofner, Harold Jackson, Cliff Branch, Mac Speedie, Billy Howton, Otis Taylor and Drew Pearson are in a tier below Sharpe in my book. Of those seven, I don't know how to rank them exactly. Any of these seven receivers could replace Brazile on my top 10 snubs list with a good argument from someone on the forum.
*Others I considered- Erich Barnes, Charley Brock, Larry Grantham, Winston Hill, E.J. Holub, Jimmy Patton, Louis Wright, Bryant Young, Joe Klecko, L.C. Greenwood, George Christensen, Maxie Baughan, Jim Tyrer, Mark Bavaro, Sam Mills, Bobby Dillon, Albert Lewis, Terrell Davis, Kurt Warner, Priest Holmes, Verne Lewellen, Ox Emerson, Don Perkins, Ken Anderson and Cliff Harris.
*I am not sure any of these would make my personal Hall of Fame. I will actually put together such a thing but I have to develop some particular criteria first.
I had Bryant Young noted as a HOF snub. I open myself up for clown consideration, of course.