Johnny Robinson or Eddie Meador?

[HBGFBFAN]

Better player and who is more deserving of being in the Hall of Fame?

[bachslunch]

Better player and who is more deserving of being in the Hall of Fame?

I think both are very deserving, but:

--I'd choose Robinson (6/7/allAFL) over Meador (3/6/60s) given their honors profiles and

--Robinson (8.2) grading out better at Ken Crippen's film study site than Meador (7.7).

[JohnTurney]

Robinson

[Reaser]

Robinson. There's a lot of 'borderline' guys where 'we' say it's ridiculous they're not in, but in his case, it truly is ridiculous he's not in. He's not borderline at all, in my opinion.

[oldecapecod11]

In Truth, the question should never even come before the house...

The nineteen-sixties were a time of turmoil, vision, and change. The Cold War; the Kennedys; the race for the moon.
Personally, it was the decade of my marriage, and the births of my children: in short, the best time of my life. In sports, too,
the winds change were blowing: goodbye, Bronko Nagurski, George Halas, three yards and a cloud of dust.
Hello, Lance Alworth, Tom Sestak, Joe Namath and Johnny Robinson.
So long to the Browns' orange pumpkins, hello to the 'Bolts!
The 'sixties: it was Camelot, it was the Beatles, it was Mare Tranquilitatis, it was "Aquarius": it was the AFL.
~ Ange Coniglio

http://www.remembertheafl.com/AFL.htm

[JoeZagorski]

Johnny Robinson. I've been laboring in trying to get the HOF to induct him every year for the past several years.
Joe Zagorski