Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

Getting back to Shofner, he along with Carroll Dale both could have had better careers without the Rams offensive ineptness. Waterfield could play but wasn't much of a coach and only Red Phillips seemed to play well after Shofner left. Could Van Brocklin had thrived more with Shofner in LA had he s...

Appreciate the additional information on Shofner I agree that the rams indecisiveness in terms of Shofner cost him a hof spot

Sharpe getting elected could also help other players with high peak-short careers but it will be interesting if his election helps Dilweg, Lewellen and Isbell down the road? I know Isbell gets support but I feel he also could be cancelling them out as well. I feel Lewellen will only have a chance a...

Nothing like a punter getting ranked ahead of a good, tough player in Landry, who became a great Giants coach. Disrespect if you ask me. Coaching should be an extension of the player in respect to team history. Maybe it's truly about just the players, which I understand but doesn't do a team's hist...

Sharpe getting elected could also help other players with high peak-short careers but it will be interesting if his election helps Dilweg, Lewellen and Isbell down the road? I know Isbell gets support but I feel he also could be cancelling them out as well. I feel Lewellen will only have a chance a...

Am I crazy to think Erich Barnes is ranked too low Not crazy. Very reasonable. Did his best work as NYG ... if they are putting guys who played 2½ years as a NYG ahead of him ... then him playing for Chi and Cle cannot be held against him. If they hadn't put Cal Hubbard to high, then maybe you coul...

Am I crazy to think Erich Barnes is ranked too low

One other player I will add and just thought of is Joe Fortunato even though he was a 1950s all decade selection his best years were in the 60's

BW I'll agree on the following Cherry Martin Parrish Patton Jake Scott Maybe Smerlas Absolutely Not Brito for a variety of reasons one being let's get Jacoby in the hall first Any super senior because unfortunately that ship has sailed Again JMO How would you define a super senior? Mainly players w...

BW I'll agree on the following


Cherry

Martin

Parrish

Patton

Jake Scott

Maybe

Smerlas

Absolutely Not

Brito for a variety of reasons one being let's get Jacoby in the hall first

Any super senior because unfortunately that ship has sailed

Again JMO