Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

Staffords the fastest QB in NFL history to reach 50k yards. He was 1 nice pass away from throwing for 5k yards twice. He averages 275 yards a game over his career(4th in NFL history) 10 more than Tom Brady,5 more than Peyton, 15 more than Rodgers. Now calling him better than those guys based on jus...

I think the semi list was more controversial by far. This list doesn't really have any surprises compared to that one. All the usual suspects are here. I have a feeling this will be one of those years where other than Ware the HOF mainly inducts candidates who've been waiting for awhile. IMO Hester ...

How could Stafford be the most "underhonored" player in NFL History when every day (it seems) we are told someone obviously deserving has been excluded from the Pro Football Hall of Fame (or the PFRA Hall of Very Good)? Surely those heinous slights far exceed any injustices done to poor o...

Stafford's numbers are far from incredible. I have nothing against Stafford -- in fact I kind of like him. But I'd have to agree with that statement. Forget Rodgers and Brees; just look at Stafford's stats and then check out Kirk Cousins, who beats him in just about every category. And I don't hear...

Strongly disagree with winning being a factor for the QB to the extent it has become. It's a team game and one player even the QB does not have responsiblity for the whole outcome. Also one of his playoff losses should have been a win on the sporting merit. Whose to say they couldn't have had a cind...

While the media can be wrong and every year is different usually a transcendent talent gets their share of honors if they have a long career. I think Stafford only making 1 pro bowl is unprecedented given the level of production he's had. I previously considered Boldin the most underrated skill play...

Box is very underrated thank you for bringing him up. He scored the same amount of touchdowns as Kutner in 1 more game and had 2 10 td seasons. He just needed a little more longevity for his career to be appreciated.

Eddie George is the most interesting selection IMO. I have him second among that large cluster of non all decade RB's drafted in the late 90s and early 2000s behind Corey Dillon. They are mostly on the wrong side of borderline IMO but this offers insight into how the HOF voters rank this cluster of...

Good calls Zero26 but Rice has an uphill climb with pass rushers Ware, Allen, Mathis and soon Freeney and Peppers coming up ... Suggs will get alot of attention as well with his ability to have many run-stuffs, tackles as well as sacks. Lets say Barber gets in and now theyre four defenders from tha...

Youre right Robert, all true but Hester was not much of a receiver or starter and Herschel Walker and Eric Metcalf had better careers as starters, along with Steve Smith and Derrick Mason, who all excelled on special teams. I will admit, Hester is the best punt returner EVER but 38 total career TDs...